June 25th Vintages release – Some terrific bargains and one or two bigger buck highlights.

School is out and as if on cue the LCBO makes at least two bargain priced (for them) high quality wines available for summer quaffing. Whether you’re at the cottage, around the pool, or just when the kids become too much these wines’ll provide inexpensive ‘go to’ enjoyment. The best of these cheap and cheerful wines are sophisticated, somewhat complex, and only $15.  Even better, it appears the LCBO has purchased  the wines in industrial quantities so there’ll be no shortage of them for quite some time. You might consider case lots anyway though!

I had been looking forward to the Argentina focus in this release but it is a bit of a disappointment. Completely overshadowed  by  the quality bargains in the  balance of the release, it seems to be  a rehash of almost ‘general list’  type wines. The wines presented from Argentina are all good wines  but  when the LCBO puts a region in focus, they should be striving to present  good,  better,  and  best.  And they should strive to present  regional greatness, not just more of the same. Oh, and price them competitively with the best of the pricing that is available less than an hour away.  From the LCBO HQ -  take the Gardner/QEW combo, drive west, then  south, then east, across the bridge over the Niagara river if you need to find pricing samples.  Is this asking too much? Rhetorical, I know.

In this release there is also a July 1^st Canada Day focus. Nationalists might find pleasure in one of two Ontario white wines:  the Gretzky Sauvignon Blanc from Niagara or the Huff chardonnay from the cool climate PEC.

The Best for the Least 

Perrin Vinsobres Les Cornuds 2009– $15. A high quality Cotes du Rhone Villages from the excellent 2009 vintage, this wine is a blend of Syrah and Grenache and annually rates around 90 points from all the reviewers. The 2009 vintage should be that good or better and provide drinking enjoyment for a few years. The hard part will be letting it age that long.  Unlike my next recommended wine you can serve this with anything from grilled lamb chops to roasted or  rotissereed chicken. A food match  here if you have a Starsky’s nearby. Stop in for their vacuum packed sun dried tomato and basil flattened chicken. Amazingly good on the ‘Q and I think it’ll pair nicely with this wine.

Marquis Phillips Shiraz 2008 – This time from Oz, another $15 beauty for those who like to get their new world fruit via viscose, teeth staining, palate coating,  almost black, purple  fluids. Great around the BBQ, it’ll stand up to anything grilled, spicey  and smoky but is also an easy quaffer.  Quaffers  beware though. This is a 16% alchoholic exocet.  Is that a hole in your hull or have you had too many glasses of this wine?  Ahhh, it’s  an Argentina theme this week so  what would these  wine reviews be without at least one Falklands war reference – even if the wine in question  isn’t Argentinian? 

Mulderbosch Rose – A Cab Sauv rose for $12.95. Annually, one of my favourite roses.  Great on a sunny deck with seafood antipasto, grilled shrimp, chicken satays, soft cheeses or just by itself. Serve nicely chilled and buy lots.

Gladiator Primitivo – Cousin (uncle?  grandfather?) to zinfandel, this is annually a very good primitivo and available for a not too bad price of  $15.95. Another wine to be enjoyed in the presence of charred meat  or while fighting Goths, or both.

2007 Cotes Du Rhone Visan Garde des Lions – From the terrific 2007 Vintage, this just sneaks in under $15 but should be right in its drinking window now.

A Spanish equivalent from  TORRES,  GRAN SANGRE DE TORO RESERVA 2007 at $ 15.95 should be a not bad Spanish take on a Southern Rhone blend

2007 MALBEC CARLA CHIARO $14.95 – Ready to drink and a buy at under $15.

Ben Marco Cabernet Sauvignon and the Zuccardi Q are OK. The Ben Marco might be the better buy at $16.95

Altocedro’s Tempranillo will be a good choice for something a little different.  Might provide an opportunity for a new world vs old world tempranillo throwdown $16.95

Cheap Whites?

Alamos Chardonnay at 13.95

SOLAR DAS BOUÇAS LOUREIRO VINHO VERDE – if you’re looking for something white,  light and refreshing, with just a hint o’ frizzante, try this vinho verde from Portugal. $13.95

So there they are, 11 wines all under $17.

The Big Buck Wines

There aren’t many that stood out but there is a pair of Italians that caught my eye.

The Viticcio Chianti Classico reserva 2007 is my first choice. The ’06 was super, and the ’07 should be even better. Worth picking some up and leaving them for a while in a cool dark place. Open with some friends who’ll appreciate them.

Strap on your helmet if you’re going after the POGGIO SCALETTE IL CARBONAIONE 2007. It appears to be almost 10 bucks less than the ’06 for perhaps a slightly better vintage. Even at almost 60 bucks the 97 points will have the door crashers out to load up.  I’d let them battle for it and grab a few of the Chianti above instead.

If you like OLD…

MONTIVERDI VIGNETO CIPRESSONE CHIANTI CLASSICO 1998 $ 24.95 – If you want to see how some of the ’06 or ’07 Chianti Classicos will age, the LCBO has a ’98 available in this release for under $25. Nice for those who like some maturity in your wines.

Veneto and Dad's day are nothing special - the June 11 Vintages release

Let's start with special thanks to Rick from Ottawa and Laura from Guelph for their comments on the Dandelion Shiraz. Don't be shy, folks, feel free to add your 2 cents worth!

This week’s focus is on another of the big 3 Italian regions. This time around it’s Veneto, home of Amarones and Valpolicellas among others but I didn’t see much to enthuse me. As well, there  appears to be almost an afterthought entry for Father’s day. For that, there are some big buck selections that are just too much for this time of year.

Summer is here and I find myself really busy so for the next little while you’ll find me cutting back on my entries and just highlighting the wines I’m considering.  My first choices are:

Gigondas La Cave L’intense Gigondas 2007 – From a renowned year in the Southern  Rhone at $26.95 I’ll be picking up a few of these.

Castello De Gabbiano Chianti Classico Reserva 2007 – $22.95 Also great vintage in Chianti, this one can be enjoyed now or be good for a short lay down.

Pascuale Pelissero Bricco San Giuliano Barbaresco 2007 – Should be an excellent wine especially with food. Decant this one and let it breathe for a time. $27.95

Now lets move on to an under $20 Shirazfest. Ok so maybe it’s a syrahfest too but it’s a fest….

For me, the first choice in the fest will be the Thelema Shiraz 2006 – For a buck or two more than the following pair of Aussie Shiraz, spring for this South African beauty! It should be big and bold – a superb wine at this price point. $19.95.

A pair of entry level shiraz from two great Aussie  producers,  Elderton and Barossa Valley Estates. Both are within a buck of one another and both very good for the price. Elderton Friends and BVE E minor shiraz should be great BBQ wines for casual get togethers  and BBQs.

Jean Claude Fromont Le Comte de Parme Crozes Hermitage 2009. A really well priced syrah from another great vintage in the Rhone. $16.95

Last entry in the ‘fest is the Falernia Reserva Syrah 2007 from the Elqui Valley in Chile. 90 points from Jay Miller and only $15.95, this should not disappoint. I’m not familiar with the producer, nor the region, so it slips down in my ratings.

The near misses:

Catena Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 from Argentina. Terrific producer, good solid wine. Are you grilling something red?  You’ll never be disappointed with this one. $19.95

Vitalonga Terra di Confine 2006  $22.95 Might be the sleeper of the release, especially if you are a Vino Nobile de Montepulciano fan.

 Castiglion Del Bosco Rosso di Montalcino 2006 – At $19.95, this should be a very nice on its own but even better with food.

Bodegas Hermanos Laredo Senorio de Laredo gran reserva 1998. Yes, 1998 and  $25.95. For you fans of older wines who can’t wait for your own stash to age.

Last but not least, if you are looking for something really special for your wine cellar, there is an ISD that could be the ticket. A 3000 ml (4 normal bottles) of the 2006 Barone Ricasoli Castello di Brolio Chianti Classico for $247.95. This wine was #5 on the WS TOP 100 of 2009 and is a terrific wine that’ll age gracefully until that special big event.  Very few bottles of it are available though!

May 28th release - nothing too exciting to me....

In spite of the California focus, the Vintages Release out May 28 does not show much to get 

too excited about. I might chase down the Eberle (eh-burr-lee) Cab but that’s about all.

SANTA JULIA MAGNA 2009 ( Familia Zuccardi) $14.95 – Well priced red blend

135202 KAIKEN ULTRA CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2007 $19.95 – Good Cab – where are the burgers and the steak?

BRITISH COLUMBIA

BURROWING OWL CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2008 $56.95 – An ISD so it’ll be rare,but well made, good Canuck producer.

ONTARIO

FIELDING RED CONCEPTION 2008 $18.95 – Worth a try but expect more green/brown scents and flavours than red and black fruits.

New Zealand

 Lawsons Sauvignon Blanc - $16.95 – Very well priced for a 91 point savvy

 PROVENCE

CHATEAU LA TOUR DE L'EVEQUE VENDANGES $17.95

Italy

PIEDMONT

RENATO RATTI MARCENASCO BAROLO 2006 $49.95 – Previous vintage was Top 7 in the WS Top 100 so you know it’s a good producer.  

PUGLIA

APOLLONIO TERRAGNOLO PRIMITIVO 2004 $17.95 – Always enjoy the Apollonios. Big, great mouthfeel with some age on this one.

TUSCANY

I GREPPI GREPPICANTE BOLGHERI 2007 $23.95 – Mid twenties for a  WSTop 100 wine? Yes indeed, even if it is the second pass for this one.

BARONE RICASOLI CASALFERRO 2006  $39.95- Big Bucks, big flavours.

CALIFORNIA

EBERLE VINEYARD SELECTION CABERNET $23.95 – The previous release of this Cab was really really good. Only downside was the plastic cork. Wait a sec, if a cork is made of plastic, does that make it a plastic and not a cork?  If so, the only downside to this last time was the plastic plastic. Note to Eberle  and to the LCBO -  For Eberle - Real cork or a screwcap please and for the LCBO - two dollars less on the price.

STAG'S LEAP WINE CELLARS ARTEMIS CABERNET $49.95

FREEMARK ABBEY CABERNET SAUVIGNON $29.95

FESS PARKER RODNEY'S VINEYARD SYRAH 2007 $39.95 – Serve with raccoon. (Think about it, you’ll get it eventually.)

Spain

Ardahl Crainza 2005 - $16.95 and ready to be served with food.

The conspiracy theory plot thickens further!

Many Thanks to reader Rick from Ottawa for his post in the Comments section regarding Dandelion's Lionheart Shiraz. For those too lazy to check the comments section, Rick said:

"Hello, I just finished the last bottle of Dandelion we had from last year. Fortunately we purchased 12 at the time and enjoyed every one for special occasions. The lot from last years distribution I had was L10046. We just purchased several bottles today and the lot is L0230. Haven't tried it yet, but will let you know how it is for comparison."

Now the plot truly does thicken. If I'm understanding the lot numbers right, Rick's last bottle of last year's release  was produced on the 46th day of 2010 (Feb.15th). Rick's  most recently purchased bottle matches the ones I bought - L0230, which I interpret to be day 230, 2010. Mine  has a time of 09:33 and an L1 etched in the bottle. I read the notes from Dandelion's site last summer but I'm not sure how Dandelion knew prior to June  they HAD bottled only 1103 cases if they didn't bottle this wine until day 230 - August 18th.

SO, methinks the LCBO has some 'splainin to do - or at least they should do as much of a comparison as they can between the two wines. Meantime on to my unscientific taste test. I hope Rick will respond with his 2 cents worth as well when he tries the latest release.

I popped and poured mine on Friday evening, shortly after a 5 minute car ride from the LCBO.  Initial aromas of black fruit and hints of mint. Maybe some rotting, make that ageing, meat (or bacon/ smoked meat combo -  either way to me that's a good thing!).  First taste, lots of fruit - very nice with a slight olive tapenade. Full notes across the palate and a nice, long finish. The fruit lasted through the first glass ( Reidel syrah stemware). Second glass had the fruit fading for me and by the third I found that, by and large,  the fruit component had left the building leaving mostly alchoholic, earthy notes with just a hint of chemical after taste.

So, my recommendation? Open with company,  pour 4 or more big glasses and drink them right away. Not like shooters but don't linger too long over them! This is one wine that does not seem to appreciate air much.

Quality wise, this Lionheart was not up to the version I drank last year. I do still have another bottle from this release. I'll give it some time in a cool dark place and will try it then see if it comes around any more.

For now, this skeptical reviewer suggests a name change to Lionheart of the Bait and Switch.

May 14, 2011 - A great release with a conspiracy theory added in for spice!

Another very nice release… Two focal points this time around. One of my favourite regions,  the Southern Rhone,  and  for those soon to come hot spring days on the deck, Rosé wines. There are at least 10 different wines in this release that I am seriously considering buying. Yes 10, and yes seriously!


But let’s start the reviews with a focus on two possibly outstanding but also possibly ‘WTF is this crap?’ wines – one from Argentina and one from Oz.


First, the Argentinian, the 2007 Norton Privada - $21.95 : 91 points from Parker and Spectator, 92 points from BP but BP has also scored it substantially less than that! See my notes from a week or two ago. This one could be one of the best wines you’ve ever had under $22 - or one of the most dreadful! Look for a new note on one of my other bottles just before release.


The second one I wonder about is the 2008 Dandelion Vineyards Lionheart of the Barossa Shiraz. A return of what I thought was one of last summer’s classiest labels and most pleasant Shiraz surprises. I bought one bottle but didn’t get around to trying it until much later in the year. To my disappointment then it was sold out or I’d have gone back to buy more. But, while it is nice to see the same vintage back for an encore, I have warning bells going off on my blog. Not warning bells to tell you to rush out and buy the wine, but rather to tell you why perhaps you should not. 
Vintages release of the 2008 last June was very, very good but last year the the winery’s own notes said only 1103 cases were made. They’ve since removed that from their website.Between the 239 cases bought by the Monopoly last year and the 799 this time around, that means the LCBO bought over 94% of the winery’s production of  2008 Lionheart of the Barossa. Does this seem reasonable considering the strong Australian press and very good scores that this vintage of the wine garnered (92 to 95 points across the board)? All of Oz and the rest of the world bought only 65 cases or so? Good for us if the LCBO did get that much of the original 2008 batch but let’s face it, the LCBO is not renowned for their ability to sniff out and buy up the entire vintage of a really good ‘under the NA radar’ wine! So we have a ‘buyer beware’ situation because to this skeptical wine lover it appears there can only be three other explanations and none of them are positive.
If they didn’t buy 94% of the entire vintage, are our friends at the LCBO trying to find ways to guarantee sales by conspiring with the producer to use an old ‘bait and switch’ tactic?  That is, they bait us with a very good, well priced wine that’ll sell based on very strong word of mouth from last summer’s release. Meanwhile they knowingly switch in a subpar second run of the wine for the original. The LCBO wouldn’t do that, would they? The second even more insidious explanation is that the winemakers in Oz are finding ever more questionable ways to try to reduce their grape glut. Did Dandelion get the good scores and then, unknown to the LCBO, did they pull a Schild Estate? Schild Estate’s Shiraz was the number 10 wine in last year’s WS Top 100. Very good for a roughly mid twenty $ wine. Except that Schild  restarted producing, bottling and selling that vintage of their supposed estate wine long after the WS Top 100 had been printed and long after they had exhausted their ‘estate’ grape crop. Such a practice is not illegal, but very questionable, I’d say. So I’m wondering, did Dandelion take a page from Schild and remake another batch of their high scoring wine not from their own, advertised, ancient vines but rather from bought Barossa grapes or juice? If the latter is the case, this wine is untasted and untested against all the previous high scoring reviews and may be setting us up for a disappointment. Time will tell but for now BP  recommends that if you buy multiples of this wine try one quickly. Also, check the lot numbers to see when the lot was produced. And see if all the cases in your store are from the same lot number. If you still happen to have a bottle at home from last year’s June Vintages release, check it to see if the production lot number is the same too. Use the comments section below, because I’d sure like to know! The third option is that they actually produced more than 1103 cases. But then why state that number on their site? It’s either incompetence or a nasty practice to heighten demand and one that calls into question the producer’s integrity.  


Indeed there may be a grassy knoll in the Dandelion Vineyard but that’s enough conspiracy theories for now…on to the other great wines in the release!

The REDS

The aforementioned Lionheart of the Barossa and Norton Privada are joined by a number of superb mid to upper priced Rhone offerings. I’d pick them in this order:

2009 Perrin 'La Gille' Gigondas -$29.95: Nice. Great producer, great  wine, great region, great vintage. A little pricey but absolutely worth it to me.  Very ageworthy, drink now after decanting or age in a quiet dark place.

2009 Domaine Alain Jaume Grand Veneur 'Grande Garrigue' Vacqueyras - $22.95 : Similar to the Gigondas but a bit more fruit forward, slightly less tannic structure, not quite as ageworthy but oh so good. Alain Jaume is a first class producer as well.

2009 Vignerons de Caractere Seigneur de Fontimple Vacqueyras - $18.95 : Another very good one at a very good price!

2009 Ogier Marquis de Valclair  Gigondas $23.95 – A very well priced Gigondas but one designed for food.

And then follow them with two Cotes Du Rhone Villages which are too well priced to pass up:

2009 Domaine le Grand Retour Plan de Dieu Cotes du Rhone-Villages - $13.95 : Tremendous wine  at a really attractive price.

Le Gravillas Sablet  2009 – $14.95 Another beauty at a really great price!

Italy

2007 Avignonesi Vino Nobile de Montepulciano $29.95 – Not cheap but like the Perrin Gigondas, worth every penny. Big, juicy, licorice, and black fruits. Brought a bottle back from BC and it was excellent – right in its drinking window too. A WS Top 100 pick from last year.

More Oz

Two Hands Gnarly Dudes 2009 $27.95 – Two Hands is a proud, preeminent Australian vintner. This wine is traditionally a 89-90 pointer so scoring 93 points from Harvey Steiman is a coup. I expect it may be a WS Top 100 for 2011 if this score holds up.

2008 Chapel Hill McLaren Vale Cabernet Sauvignon or Shiraz- Both at $24.95 Two more James Halliday 95, 94 point scores which probably translate to 91 pointers in the real world, but look for big, big McLaren Vale black fruits, judicious oak and an evolution of flavours and aromas in your glass. 
Whoops, Two I forgot - The Filsell Shiraz from Grant Burge, probably the best Shiraz in the release and the D'Arenberg Laughing Magpie Shiraz Viognier. For those who think a Shiraz Viognier mix is a strange one, remember it is the traditional Cote Roti blend. The viognier ads perfume to the syrah to round out the nose and to a degree the palate. Both these wines are hard to beat and of the two, in spite of only getting 89 from Parker's minion, I'd pick up a few Filsell's. Both are hard to beat!  

Washington State

2007 Dusted Valley Boomtown Columbia Valley Cabernet Sauvignon - $19.95 : Burgers? Steaks? Smoked pulled pork? All the above? This bad boy will be there! Another really good Washington State midpriced Cabernet.

Spain

2004 Ondarre Rioja Reserva - $19.95 : Great score, a WS Top 100 and under $20 bucks.

2006 Viticultors del Priorat Vega Escal - $18.95 : A Priorat for under $20? Niiiice.  

2009 Dehesa Gago - $14.95 : Worth a flyer.

California

2008 Joseph Phelps Innisfree Napa Cabernet Sauvignon - $37.95 Always very good but priced out of range with the other quality wines in this release.

The Rosés

Peninsula Ridge Beal Vineyard Cabernets $11.95 -  Local talent and tasty

Muga $12.95 – Pink grapefruit light and dry. Great with all sorts of tapas.

Finca Alcayata Malbec Rosado $12.95 – nice, a bit more of a mouthful.

Kim Crawford Pansy $16.95 – A few bucks more but usually worth it.

Zenato Bardolino Chiaretto $11.95 – Antipasto anyone?

Malivoire Ladybug $15.95 – A few bucks more than most but a local favourite.

The Whites

2006 Naveran Dama Cava $17.95 – Want a good inexpensive sparkler? Try this one from Spain.

A trio of Chardonnays - 2009 Mulderbosch Chardonnay - $19.95; 2009 Wynns Coonawarra Chardonnay - $17.95 ; Kim Crawford Unoaked Chardonnay $17.95.

2010 Dog Point Vineyard Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc - $19.95 : Might not be up to previous standards but usually a fave.

2009 Sols & Sens Cotes du Rhone-Villages Laudun Blanc - $13.95 : A gold in the  2010 International Wine Challenge, this is a blend of the traditional Rhone white grapes for a different white experience.

Port Anyone?

Graham's Six Grapes Reserve Port - $20.95 – A tasty little bottle for ‘after dinner’ing. Where’s that stilton?

My Picks? In this order…

Perrin’s Gigondas

Alain Jaume’s Vacqueyras

Avignonesi’s Vino Nobile de Montepulciano

The Gnarly Dudes and the Ondarre rioja and with the caveats, Norton Privada and Lionheart all in a dead heat,

The Filsell, Magpie and both Chapel Hills in a tie with the 2 Cotes du Rhone Villages and the Boomtown Cab.

And then the Rosés in the order above and maybe the Cava and the KC Unoaked Chard

Good grief, at some point fiscal responsibility has to take over….someone save me from myself!

Vintages April 30 release - First Families of Australian Wines combined with Southern Italy

The big feature in this release focuses on The First Families of Australian wines. My Pick of the release. 2008 Jim Barry 'The Lodge Hill' Shiraz - $23.95 Always very good, olive tapenade, meat, nori, black cherries, good mouth feel. Nice with anything grilled or on its own.
 AUSTRALIA FEATURE 
Any of the following wines will be very good too:
2008 Howard Park Leston Cabernet Sauvignon - $29.95 :  Big cab from Western Australia. Expect  subtlety smokiness and tobacco notes -  more old world in style than your typical Oz cabs.
2006 Tahbilk Nagambie Lakes Shiraz - $19.95 : A four point swing between scores in the WS and RP, but worst case, its a really good wine at the price. Best case? A screaming bargain!
2008 Wakefield Cabernet Sauvignon - $17.95 – Quality for the price.
2008 Jim Barry 'The Cover Drive' Cabernet Sauvignon - $23.95 : Always really good. Past bottles have needed some time to settle in before being opened. Not long mind you but a few months in a dark quiet place rounded them out nicely.
2008 Tyrrell's Heathcote Rufus Stone Shiraz - $19.95 : Annually a well priced ready to drink and easy drinking big wine.
2008 Yalumba Patchwork  Shiraz - $21.95 : Halliday gives it 93, take it as a 90.
 SOUTHERN ITALY - SPOTLIGHT
2008 Firriato Etna Rosso - $16.95 : A Sicilian red that is not Nero D’Avola. Well priced and something a little different from the volcanic soils of Mount Etna.
2008 Terredora Aglianico - $14.95 : Aglianico can be terrific – big, juicy,  mouth filling licorice-y scents and flavours.
2006 Leone de Castris Riserva Salice Salentino - $16.95 : 50^th Anniversary of this should be super.
 The rest

ROCCA DI CASTAGNOLI POGGIO A’FRATI CHIANTI CLASSICO RISERVA 2006 – A terrific vintage, right in its drinking window $29.95

2008 Clos de los Siete - $21.95 : Always well scored, this rerelease of a Bordeaux blend from Argentina is easing toward the end of its first decade. As the vines and fruit mature the wine becomes less of a fruit bomb and more of sophisticated potable to accompany more than just grilled meats. Perhaps a bit more tannic than earlier vintages, it’ll be interesting to compare this one to the Norton Privada in the Mid May release. The Privada merited a recent special note by the way.
Rustenberg John X Merriman 2007 $27.95. – Great producer and a great region. If you liked the Chocolate Block, this’ll be more of the same. Perhaps more Bordeaux in style
1995 Don Jacopo Gran Reserva – Yes, 1995! And Yes, $27.95.
2006 Casa Gualda Plus Ultra - $13.95 : A Big powerful wine for such a little price.

Heads up for the May 14th release! It has some terrific wines.

Norton Privada 2007 - A heads up tasting note

Norton Privada 2007 – This wine is in the May 14th Vintages release. This truly is a tale of two wines. The 2007 Norton Privada received 91 points from the Wine Spectator. BP has had 4 bottles of this wine in the last 6 months and it has received 92, 72 (and 84) and 80 and 78 points from me. Two versions were procured from the BCLDB, and two from the SAQ. The first bottle was what drove me to buy a quartet from the SAQ. It was spectacular.



Eyes closed, this first bottle could have been mistaken for a $60 Napa Meritage. It displayed amazing fruit, tannins, currants, blackberry, cherry, licorice, a bit of smoke, all playing in concert together on both the nose and palate. A wonderful wine – popped and poured - the first glass had it in my Top 50 wines of the year last year. I thoroughly enjoyed the bottle last November. There’s my 92 pointer.


Now on to the SAQ version purchased during our New Year’s visit to the outlaws. No nose to speak of, tight, mouth dryingly astringent, with a chemical taste to it. What fruit there was lay concealed beneath a layer of harsh tannins. Both bottles were served with the same meal, a rib roast of pork, but the difference between them was startling especially after the buildup I had given it! My wife, who generally loves whatever I bring to the table, bluntly said, “This isn’t doing it for me” and stopped at one unfinished glass. Unheard of in our household. I did the same. But I also thought I had to give this bad boy a second chance, mostly because I brought 4 bottles home from Quebec based on the BC bottle! I corked it and put it in the fridge. 20 hours later it was released from its frigid purgatory and uncorked again to warm on the counter. A bottle of 2005 Chateauneuf du Pape was opened and decanted beside it to provide the Privada with an idea of what was expected of garnet coloured fluids in my house. How was it day two? Better after 21 hours and even better by the 23 hour mark. The fruit was beginning to make an appearance, the tannins softening and that chemical taste fading. But I think it might have needed another 24 hours and even then it would never really shine in the way the first BC bottle had right out of the gate. There’s the 72 and 84 pointer.


Recently I was back to BC and tried another bottle while there and upon returning home, I also opened another of my SAQ stash. This time around, the BC bottle seemed to be suffering from the same affliction that cursed the first of the SAQ bottles. Fruit was absent, dry, dry tannins, a chemical aftertaste, all in all a real disappointment. Opening the second SAQ bottle at home, I found it slightly better than the first after resting in the cellar for a few more weeks but still nowhere near that benchmark first bottle. There’s my 80 (SAQ) and 78 (BCLDB) pointers.


So, what’s the scoop? Has the wine just entered a developmental dumb phase? Were the bottles from two different lots that were not equal fruit wise? Was it just not as well made or was there another serious flaw in the wine or the process? Regardless, it’s spoiling Norton’s reputation. Will my last two bottles come out of this funk? Time will tell. This wine is in the May 14 release so I’ll be opening one a few days before that release to see what state it’s in. If the Privada in the LCBO release is like the first BC version and you live outside of the GTA, you should have special ordered in April because it’ll fly off the shelves and be gone. On the other hand, if we get something like the second BC bottle or any of the Quebec ones, it will be panned or ignored by anyone who tastes it. The LCBO will sell out of it but only due to the 91 point label I’m sure it’ll be wearing.